McCarthy Tétrault recognized in Lexpert Special Edition Litigation 2026 and Top 10 Business Decisions

Our Firm’s litigation and dispute resolution expertise has once again been recognized by Lexpert in its annual Special Edition: Litigation. This year, 52 of our lawyers are named among Canada's leading litigators. With the largest Litigation and Dispute Resolution team of any Canadian business law firm, our continued recognition by Lexpert and other top directories is a reflection of our exceptional depth of talent and the collaborative approach we bring to our clients’ most significant disputes.
Our lawyers recognized in the Special Edition: Litigation 2026 are:
As well, our team acted in seven of the Top 10 Canadian Business Law Decisions of 2025–2026, reflecting the calibre of our litigators and the confidence our clients place in us when results matter most.
Lundin Mining Corp. v. Markowich, 2025 SCC 39. The Firm represented two interveners, Canadian Chamber of Commerce and the Insurance Bureau of Canada, on this landmark Supreme Court of Canada decision establishing the test for when a development constitutes a “material change” under securities legislation, in the context of a motion for and addressing the threshold for leave to bring a secondary market statutory securities class action. The team included Brandon Kain and Aya Schechner for the Canadian Chamber of Commerce, and Dana Peebles and Valérie Lord for the Insurance Bureau of Canada.
SS&C Technologies Canada Corp. v. Bank of New York Mellon Corp., 2026 SCC 29. For the first time in a century, the Supreme Court of Canada clarified the rules on spoliation in a decision expected to affect the conduct of all litigation, especially complex matters between sophisticated parties. Eli Mogil, Brandon Kain, Erin Chesney and Aya Schechner represented the Bank of New York Mellon.
Baker v. Van Dolder’s Home Team Inc., 2026 ONCA 568. This landmark employment law decision provides much-needed certainty to how Ontario courts should assess the enforceability of termination clauses. It is significant for employers and employees alike across the province. Leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada has been sought by the plaintiffs. Tim Lawson, Brandon Kain, Marco Fimiani and John Gray represented Van Dolder’s Home Team.
Hvitved v. Home Depot of Canada Inc., 2026 BCCA 39. Alexandra Cocks and Connor Bildfell represented Home Depot of Canada in a B.C. Court of Appeal decision regarding a privacy class action. The Court dismissed the plaintiff's appeal and upheld the lower court’s decision to strike most of the plaintiff’s claims and certify only a small number of statutory claims for alleged breach of privacy. The decision illustrates the courts’ willingness to strike a large part of a claim at the certification stage, and offers important guidance on what is required to properly plead a breach of contract claim.
Lin v. Uber Canada Inc., 2025 FCA 183. This was the first case addressing the enforceability of Uber’s revised arbitration clause after Uber Technologies Inc. v. Heller, 2020 SCC 16. The Federal Court of Appeal upheld the Federal Court’s decision enforcing the arbitration clause, even in the context of this proposed consumer class action. The decision is also significant because the FCA rejected arguments that provincial consumer protection legislation can be used to limit the enforceability of arbitration clauses for claims under the federal Competition Act. Gillian Kerr, Patrick Williams and Tanner Lorenson successfully represented Uber on the matter.
1086289 Ontario Inc. (Urban Electrical Contractors) v. Welland (City), 2026 ONCA 352. In one of the largest claims in Canadian history to be dismissed as an abuse of process, the Court of Appeal for Ontario heard multiple appeals together, to decide when non-disclosure is an abuse of process, what remedy applies, and how the common law interacts with the recently enacted r. 49.14 of the Rules of Civil Procedure. The decision is expected to set the benchmark for obtaining a stay for abuse of process in the post-Handley era. The Firm successfully represented Providius Corp. with a team led by Anu Koshal that included Rachel Chan and Almut MacDonald.
Emond v. Trillium Mutual Insurance Co., 2026 SCC 3. In this leading decision on insurance contract interpretation, the Supreme Court of Canada provided insurers and policyholders with greater clarity on how courts interpret endorsements alongside standard form policies, and the reach of the nullification of coverage doctrine. Mathew Zaia and William G. Scott represented Farm Mutual Reinsurance Plan Inc., Canadian Association of Mutual Insurance Companies and Ontario Mutual Insurance Association, as Intervenor.
Lexpert Special Edition: Litigation 2026 also includes insights on emerging trends in business litigation and dispute resolution. Our Partners Patrick Williams and Byron Shaw met with Lexpert’s Jessica Mach to discuss recent class action trends, particularly those involving A.I. litigation and consumer protection, and Canada’s jurisdictional reach in copyright infringement and in enforcing the Competition Act.
Lexpert’s Top 10 Canadian Business Law Decisions is an eagerly awaited annual list that highlights the most significant court rulings in Canada. The Lexpert Special Edition: Litigation showcases top-ranked litigation lawyers and their exceptional efforts in defending client interests.
McCarthy Tétrault’s Litigation and Dispute Resolution Group gets to the heart of the real business issues, manages matters with objectivity and clarity and buffers your company against disruption. We do not waste time or reputation on pointless posturing. We seek satisfactory resolution or a successful outcome in court. Major businesses count on McCarthy Tétrault when they confront complex disputes, whether in Canada or internationally. Through our offices across Canada, we provide all the resources needed to handle complex and multijurisdictional disputes in either official language. Learn how our team can help you.
About McCarthy Tétrault
McCarthy Tétrault LLP provides a broad range of legal services, delivering strategic and industry-focused advice and solutions for Canadian and international interests. The Firm has a substantial presence in Canada's major commercial centres as well as in New York, London, and Santiago.
Built on an integrated approach to the practice of law and delivery of innovative client services, the Firm brings its legal talent, industry insight and practice experience to help clients achieve the results that are important to them.
For further information, or to request an interview with a McCarthy Tétrault lawyer, please contact: media@mccarthy.ca
People

Hugo Babos-MarchandPartner | Practice Lead, Litigation and Dispute Resolution (Quebec)
People.Offices.Plural Montréal, Québec City








Laura M. GillPartner | Practice Lead, Litigation and Dispute Resolution (Calgary)
People.Offices.Singular Calgary



Bryn Gray, K.C.Co-head, Indigenous Legal Matters and Projects Group | Partner
People.Offices.Singular Toronto














Eli MogilPartner | Practice Lead, Litigation and Dispute Resolution (Toronto)
People.Offices.Singular Toronto





















